Category: Mediation/Arbitration

Arbitration 101

8/29/2014

Courtroom battles can be lengthy and subject a business to lots of undesired publicity. Over the years, many businesses and individuals have decided to resolve their legal disputes using alternative dispute resolution ("ADR") methods such as mediation or arbitration. These methods are much quicker, private, and at times less costly than traditional litigation. In fact, if you were to review many of the contracts that you have entered into over the years, you would discover many businesses require disputes to be resolved using some method of ADR - typically arbitration. This post will cover the basics of arbitration and the impact of choosing arbitration over traditional litigation. For a discussion of mediation, please see our post, “The 411 on Mediation”.

What is arbitration?

Arbitration is an ADR method in which a neutral person, or a group of persons, selected by the parties renders a decision to settle a dispute after hearing each party’s side of the case and reviewing the evidence.

How does arbitration work?

It is typically initiated by an agreement to arbitrate or initiated by order of the court.
The parties must select an arbitrator. (Since arbitration is not a judicial proceeding, court rules generally do not apply. Often contracts will require that the arbitration be governed by the American Arbitration Association's ("AAA") rules, or similar arbitration guidelines. Parties should be aware that a contract requiring the use of AAA's rules does not mean that they have to use the AAA for the actual arbitration or a AAA arbitrator. Any well-trained arbitrator should be versed in AAA's rules.)
The arbitrator may hold a pre-hearing/scheduling conference with the parties.
Discovery, if any, is conducted and briefs, if any, are submitted to the arbitrator.
The actual arbitration hearing is held.
The arbitrator makes a decision, which is commonly referred to as an award.

What is the arbitrator's role?

The arbitrator is essentially the judge for the arbitration. However, unlike traditional litigation where the parties have little to no choice over which judge they get, the parties usually select the arbitrator. The arbitrator will preside over the proceedings, make rulings on briefs, resolve discovery disputes, settle evidentiary issues, evaluate the evidence presented, and then make a decision. You can choose whether the arbitrator issues a basic standard award, announcing only the outcome of the case, a reasoned award, explaining the arbitrator's reasoning behind the decision in addition to the decision itself, or a detailed award that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law in addition to the decision.

Who can serve as an arbitrator?

Anyone can serve as an arbitrator provided they have the requisite training or certification required by his or her respective state, country, or industry association. Typically, arbitrators are former judges, lawyers, or a professional with particular knowledge of the facts involved in the case.

What are the benefits of arbitration?

It is quicker and more efficient than litigation.
Less formal than litigation.
Parties have control over who will be their decision maker.
The process and the award can be completely confidential.
The process can be more collegial than litigation, and a great way to preserve business relationships.
Arbitrators typically issue the award within a set time frame after the hearing, often 30 days, whereas courts do not have similar time frames and can take months to issue an opinion.
The arbitrator's award is relatively final, because it is very hard to appeal or vacate the award.
The arbitrator's award can be confirmed by a court and become an enforceable order of the court.

What are the risks of arbitration?

While discovery is limited, an arbitrator can order witnesses to appear and can order the inspection of records, letters, and other evidence.
The rules of evidence are more relaxed, so evidence that might be inadmissible in a court proceeding could be admissible in the arbitration.
There is no case precedent, meaning decisions from similar cases do not govern the arbitrator's decision and the arbitrator's award has no impact on future cases. Likewise, arbitrators are not constrained by statutes.
The arbitrator's award is relatively final, because it is very hard to appeal or vacate the award.
Arbitration can be more costly than traditional litigation.

Arbitration vs. Mediation

The goal of arbitration is for a third party to reach a decision for the parties involved in a case, while the goal of mediation is for the parties to resolve the case themselves. In arbitration, the decision is made entirely by the arbitrator. On the other hand, in mediation the mediator hears each party’s side of the case and then assists the parties in negotiating with the hopes that the parties can reach a settlement. It is possible that parties will participate in a mediation, fail to reach a resolution, and then engage in arbitration regarding the same dispute.

Deciding whether to litigate, mediate, or arbitrate can be difficult. There are benefits and risks with all three. If you would like to discuss your legal matter and the various avenues available for resolution, or you are looking for an experienced neutral to serve as either an arbitrator or mediator for your case, please do not hesitate to contact Simmons Rogers, LLC at 404-445-8260 or [email protected].

Comments

The 411 on Mediation

12/20/2013

Comments

Mediation is an effective way to resolve any type of dispute; from squabbles between neighbors to large claims worth millions of dollars. Differences that cannot be resolved between the parties can lead to expensive, time consuming, public battles that involve lawyers and courts - unless alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, like mediation, are utilized.

Mediation is a great way for businesses and individuals to resolve problems. Even after a lawsuit has been initiated, mediation is a practical way of reaching an agreement that could end the lawsuit. As long as the parties involved in the dispute are willing to meet to discuss the issues separating them, it is likely that a mutually agreeable settlement can be reached.

What is mediation?

Mediation is an opportunity for a mediator to facilitate a mutually acceptable settlement agreement between the parties involved by offering the parties an opportunity to:

Express and address their respective concerns;
Better understand the other party’s perspective; and
Help the parties involved find creative solutions to their problems.

What is the role of a mediator?

A mediator is a third party neutral that will find points of agreement between the parties and facilitate movement towards a mutually decided upon agreement. A mediator should not dictate the decision, but instead help the parties develop their own resolution.

What is the benefit of mediation?

Mediation has several benefits that make it more beneficial than arbitration and litigation in certain contexts:

Mediation saves time: Unlike litigation, which can take years, and arbitration, which can take months, the parties' dispute could potentially be resolved in a matter of days and possibly hours.
Mediation offers privacy: If the parties reach a mutually acceptable settlement agreement during the mediation, the parties' have the opportunity to restrict public exposure of the issues and the outcome.
Mediation can save relationships: When there is an interest by either party to preserve a business or personal relationship, mediation is a great alternative. Unlike litigation, the focus of mediation is on compromise - not winning and losing. With that in mind, it is possible for the dispute to be resolved in a way that allows the parties to maintain their relationship and continue to work together.
Mediation puts the parties in control: If the parties choose to litigate or arbitrate a third-party makes the final decision and the parties have no input on the final decision. However, in mediation each party gets to make the final decision about what they will and will not do. That gives the parties autonomy and control over the outcome of the dispute. Contrarily, in litigation the parties have little to no control over deadlines, hearing scheduling, or the outcome.
Mediation saves money: Mediation can save the parties money if they reach a settlement agreement by reducing the future legal fees - including discovery expenses, expert costs, and attorneys' fees - that would be incurred with continued litigation or arbitration. The parties also have the potential to save money because the party gets to decide how much it is willing to pay, instead of a judge, jury, or arbitrator.

Once the parties agree on dates, mediations can be scheduled quickly. Remember, the advantages of mediation over litigation include privacy, reduced legal fees, control over the outcome, control of the process, a chance to salvage relationships, and control of your most important asset - your time.

Simmons Rogers, LLC provides mediation services throughout Georgia, in all 50 states, and internationally. Contact us to learn more about our services or to schedule your mediation. Online scheduling is also available.

Comments

Introducing Simmons Rogers, LLC

11/5/2013

Comments

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

For more info contact:
Maya Simmons Rogers
404-445-8260
Simmons Rogers, LLC

Maya Simmons Rogers announces the opening of the law firm of Simmons Rogers, LLC

Atlanta‚ Georgia − 11/05/2013 − After much prayer and preparation, it is a pleasure to announce that Simmons Rogers, LLC is open for business. Simmons Rogers, LLC is a full service civil law firm based in Atlanta, Georgia serving clients throughout Georgia and beyond. Based at 3350 Riverwood Parkway SE, Suite 1900, Atlanta, Georgia, 30339, Simmons Rogers is conveniently located near I-285, 1-75, and Cobb Parkway.

Simmons Rogers, LLC specializes in providing skilled and knowledgeable legal services in the following areas:

Business Law: including business formations, contracts, copyrights, litigation, and trademarks
Family Law: including adoptions, child support, custody, divorces, legitimation, and name changes

Personal Injury Law: including automobile accidents, slip and falls, premise liability, and wrongful death

Wills, Trusts, and Estate Planning Law: including wills, trusts, advanced directives, and estate litigation

Feel free to share this information with your friends, colleagues, and family; and if we can ever be of service do not hesitate to contact us.

You can find out more at www.simmonsrogerslaw.com
Like us on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/simmonsrogerslaw
Follow us on Linkedin at http://www.linkedin.com/company/simmons-rogers-llc

Simmons Rogers, LLC, a civil law firm for discerning clients, was founded in 2013 by Maya Simmons Rogers. Simmons Rogers, LLC provides a wide-range of legal services for businesses and individuals. For more information about our firm or to schedule a consultation, please contact us at [email protected] or 404-445-8146.

Comments

Arbitration 101

The 411 on Mediation

Introducing Simmons Rogers, LLC

Simmons Rogers, LLC

Archives

Categories